The Proud Boys, a punch-happy extremist gang whose members spend their time harassing people online and attacking them in real life, fell apart at the seams last week as the rest of the country gave thanks.
Over the course of the Thanksgiving holiday, the Proud Boys were revealed as an extremist group in the eyes of the FBI; saw their leader, Vice Media co-founder Gavin McInnes, publicly bail on them; added two of their members to a growing list of defendants in a rioting case in New York City; and named a new leader in Jason Lee Van Dyke, their lawyer who himself is a serial harasser and racist criminal.
Today’s Proud Boys are not the same as yesterday’s Proud Boys, who just last month bragged that they had the support of police after beating protesters in the streets of New York City and Portland, Oregon.
These Proud Boys are being proudly thrown under the bus by their misogynistic and destructive founder. Immediately after that weekend of coastal violence in October, McInnes said publicly that he was arranging for the surrender of the members involved. Eight of them now face charges of assault and rioting in New York City.
Then last Monday it was revealed that the FBI classified the Proud Boys as an extremist group. Suddenly it wasn’t just the media and watchdog groups calling them a violent hate group that counts white nationalists and skinheads among its ranks and publicly portrays racist and sexist sentiments. Now the government was involved, and for McInnes, the FBI designation was the straw that broke the Proud Boys’ back.
Two days later, he claimed that he was quitting the gang, if only because his departure might reduce his jailed members’ sentences in some way.
“I’m officially disassociating myself from the Proud Boys, in all capacities, forever. I quit,” McInnes said in a rambling, 36-minute monologue on YouTube on Nov. 21.
He claimed that “lies and bad journalism” ― not the recorded violence committed by his membership ― led to his comrades’ jail time. If he pretended to leave the group, he said, the accused might receive lighter sentences. (There is no indication that the YouTube video will alter those court cases, which are set for Dec. 14.)
“I’m told by my legal team and law enforcement that this gesture could help alleviate their sentencing,” he said. “Fine. At the very least, this will show jurors they are not dealing with a gang and there is no head of operations.”
Things did not get better for the Proud Boys after McInnes’ claimed departure. Anti-fascist activists spent the holiday doxxing members — identifying them online and notifying their employers that they are members of an extremist group. They’ve claimed varying degrees of success in those endeavors.
Then, over Thanksgiving weekend, the Proud Boys released a statement, saying in one muddled breath that McInnes was never their leader but that they had chosen a new one: Van Dyke, the group’s sue-happy lawyer. Van Dyke has made national headlines before, once in 2017 for admitting to HuffPost that he threatened to kill an entire family and again this year after he was arrested for lying to police about a burglary he was involved in. (Reached for comment on that story, he told HuffPost, “Fuck you.”)
McInnes often encourages violence among his members, and the Proud Boys have been known to attack and intimidate those who oppose them. In one instance, they sent an enforcer to a Twitter videographer’s doorstep to threaten him over his content. Van Dyke is seen as a different beast, one who does all the enforcing himself, with threats of violence and lawsuits.
“Look good and hard at this picture you fucking n****r,” Van Dyke tweeted in 2014, alongside a picture of a noose. “It’s where I am going to put your neck.”
“Your kiddies are quite a nuisance,” he wrote in another tweet. “My advice: run and hide. If I find you, I WILL kill both you and your family.”
Anti-fascist activists who follow the Proud Boys’ movements wondered how the apparent leadership change might shake up the gang. After all, it still counts members across the country who are ready and eager to congregate and fight. Even though its leader is trying to bail, its members are in jail, and the government is on its tail, it’s unclear how the Proud Boys might evolve now that their ranks are crumbling.
“Will the leadership of white nationalist J.L. Van Dyke stymie their organizing? Maybe,” wrote one such activist, using the name AntiFash Gordon, on Twitter. “But only if we stop treating them like a fraternal organization and start treating them like what they are. An ultranationalist hate group led by a white nationalist.”